With one day left before baseball’s non-waiver trade deadline, Thursday started with near trade of Carlos Gomez to the Mets and ended with him going to the Astros, in addition to a massive 13 player-three team trade between the Dodgers, Braves and Marlins, and David Price being moved for the second consecutive year. Now we give the SportsZone trade grades for these three major trades from the wild day that was:

DETROIT TRADE P DAVID PRICE TO TORONTO FOR PITCHING PROSPECTS DAN NORRIS, MATT BOYD AND JAIRO LABOURT

TIGERS- A

It’s rare that the Tigers enter the trading deadline as sellers. but Detroit is hovering around .500 and the Royals are pulling away with the division, so general manager Dave Dombrowski is “rebooting” the team for the future. His first move is a great first step in that direction, as the add Norris, who is one of the top 25 prospects in baseball, but needs to command his pitchers much better but will greatly benefit from pitching in Comerica when he does return to the majors. Boyd should also be a rotation staple for the Tigers in the future, as he blew threw Double and Triple A this season before also struggling at the big league level. LaBourt is the farthest away, and needs to get work on his control, but at 21, he could be the best of the three. Dombrowski followed the model set by the Reds trade of Johnny Cueto to trade Price, another pending free agent, and by all accounts come out of it with a better return than Cincinnati got in the process.

BLUE JAYS- A

Toronto once again trades away from its prospect pitchers, as they traded away Miguel Castro and Jeff Hoffman mere days earlier, but they clearly feel that it has an offense that can compete with any team in baseball, and that Price can help the pitching enough to make a postseason run over the last two months of the season. Their starting pitching has struggled all season as they have no true ace behind RA Dickey and Mark Buerhle, while youngsters Drew Hutchinson and Aaron Sanchez have failed to take the step forward Toronto was counting on this season. Price is 9-4 with a 2.53 ERA and a K/BB ratio of 138/29 in 146 innings, and of course, is the 2012 AL Cy Young Award winner. He easily becomes the best starting pitcher in the AL East, and the Blue Jays needed that desperately if they hope to catch the Yankees or the second Wild Card spot. It’s a risk, but the player is worth it, and now the pressure is on for both Price and the Blue Jays.

DODGERS ACQUIRE Ps ALEX WOOD, MAT LATOS, LUIS AVILAN, JIM JOHNSON, BRONSON ARROYO 1B/OF MIKE MORSE AND PROSPECT 2B JOSE PERAZA; BRAVES ACQUIRE IF HECTOR OLIVERA, Ps PACO RODRIGUEZ AND ZACH BIRD, AND A COMPETITIVE BALANCE PICK FROM MIAMI; MARLINS ACQUIRE PITCHING PROSPECTS JEFF BRIGHAM, VICTOR ARAUJO, AND KEVIN GUZMAN

DODGERS- A

The Dodgers cleaned up in this deal, as they added the two starters they were craving, after season ending injuries to Hyun-jin Ryu and Brandon McCarthy have exposed their lack of pitching depth behind Clayton Kershaw, Zach Greinke, and the oft-injured Brett Anderson. Wood is a solid starter who should stay in the rotation for the foreseeable future, and while Latos is a free agent after the season, Arroyo should be healthy after Tommy John surgery next season, and was one of the more reliable pitchers in baseball before he went down last year. They also added reinforcements in the bullpen, as Avilan is consistent from the left side, and Johnson was the Braves closer this season. Olivera became a luxury for them after Justin Turners’ breakout, and Peraza should be the Dodgers starting second baseman next season, and he could easily be as valuable as top prospects Corey Seager and Julio Urias. This could put the Dodgers over the hump, and it’s safe to say anything short of a championship will be a disappointment.

BRAVES- B

The Braves pursued the 30-year-old Olivera this offseason, but were outbid by the Dodgers with a large signing bonus they didn’t want to make. Now they make the Dodgers pay over $35 million in his bonus and Arroyo’s contract and get the guy they wanted, for only $5 million a year. Bird could turn into a quality starter, the draft pick could be important and add another valuable piece next year, and Rodriguez could be a valuable bullpen arm, but the true measure of this deal will be whether Olivera will be the star Atlanta thinks he will, because Peraza is a steep price to pay.

MARLINS- D

This is one of those trades where one wonders what the Marlins are thinking. The prospect return is weak in comparison to other trades that have happened this year, and they gave up a top-45 draft pick to basically just dump salary. Latos by himself should have garnered a larger return. Instead the Marlins come out as one of the few losers in the lead-up to the trading deadline.

MILWAUKEE TRADES OF CARLOS GOMEZ AND SP MIKE FIERS TO HOUSTON FOR OF PROSPECTS DOMINGO SANTANA AND BRETT PHILLIPS AND PITCHING PROSPECTS JOSH HADER AND ADRIAN HOUSER

BREWERS- A

Not even 24 hours after almost trading the 29-year-old outfielder to the Mets for Zach Wheeler and Wilmer Flores, the Brewers turn around and trade him along with the veteran Fiers for a far superior return. Santana, long considered the steal of the Hunter Pence trade, should get an opportunity to play every day, and he has impressed over his minor league career. Phillips is the jewel of the trade, as the 21-year-old is considered the 39th best prospect in baseball (according to MLB.com), as well as one of the top outfield prospects in the game. He is currently in Double-A, and should hit for average and modest power and play a solid center field when he’s ready in 2017. Hader is a soft tossing lefty also at Double-A, but he did take a giant step forward in development last season, as he was named Player of the Year in the Single-A California League last season. Both him and Houser could turn into solid starters for the Brewers down the road. Great return all around.

ASTROS- B+

The Astros obviously had no such concerns about Gomez’ hip or hamstring, so they took the risk in adding a leadoff hitter in a down year to pair with Jose Altuve atop the lineup. Fiers may not be a great starter, but he is consistent, and will allow the struggling Scott Feldman to shift into a bullpen role for the final two months of the season. They also got lucky in being able to keep so much of its vaunted talent; as they keep outfielders Jake Marisnick, Preston Brown and pitchers Vince Velasquez, Lance McCullers, and Mark Appel in the deal too. The only negative is that Gomez is a player who relies on speed, and has had hamstring and hip issues this year. Everyone may think he’s healthy this season, and if Houston makes the playoffs it’s an obvious win. But having him during his age-30 season next year could wind up being a detriment if he starts to lose a step, or get hurt.

Related Posts:

 
 

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment